Legends of the Broadsword:
Charles Metcalfe MacGregor: A Highland Warrior in Asia
Note: In recounting the deeds of swordsmen from centuries past, I have deliberately disregarded the political context of the incidents being described, preferring to let the brave or infamous deeds of the individuals involved speak for themselves. In this case, however, there is need to say a little bit more. Charles Metcalfe MacGregor, as a soldier during the Sepoy Mutiny and the Opium Wars, was involved in conflicts about which there are strong feelings even today. As a soldier from an ancient family with a warrior heritage, his only concern was to gain glory in battle- indeed, he was somewhat obsessed with it. If he gave any thought to broader ethical or political issues, there is little hint of it in his writings. Quotes from historical letters in the following chapter contain racial slurs and other anachronisms that some readers may find offensive. They are included for historical purposes, and do not represent the views of the author or the League.
The Sikh martial art of Gatka uses a curved saber and a buckler or small round shield. The Sikhs were frequently the allies of the British in India, and Highlanders fought side by side with Sikhs to put down the Great Mutiny. A small number of Sikhs, however, were among the mutineers, and there was at least one incident in which Highlander and Sikh would seem to have crossed blades- although the broadsword man had the crucial advantage of a Colt revolver:
On reaching the breach I found it to be only a small hole, about a yard square and about the same distance from the ground. I was soon in; and as I jumped down, a man of the 93rd was killed close to my side. I also noticed Captain Burroughs bleeding from a bad sabre cut over his head. The interior of the building was full of very tall grass, a path running to the left and another to the right. I chose the latter, and on we ran, Cooper, of the 93rd—who had got through the hole just before me—displaying great gallantry. Captain Lumsden, who had been attached to my regiment as interpreter, was also with me. He was a fine fellow—an Aberdeenshire man; and as he dashed forward, he waved his sword high over his head, cheering on the Highlanders, and calling out to them to fight for the honour of Scotland. As we turned the corner, a large body of the enemy appeared in sight. They did not apparently like the look of us, for they instantly bolted through a passage to our right, which led into a sort of inner court. In a moment we were at them; but poor Lumsden was killed, and Cooper got a cut across the head. I dashed with my men into the court, and found myself face to ace with the rebels, some armed with guns, but most of them with shields and swords, or tulwahs, as they are called in India. They fired a volley directly, at a distance of only ten yards, and knocked my Highland bonnet right off my head, fortunately aiming a few inches too high.
As I was in front I could not see how many of my men fell, but at once attacked with my sword the native who appeared to be the leader. We fought for some little time, but he had a shield which gave him an advantage. He was a tall fellow, with very black eyes, and looked like a Sikh; his sword was slightly curved, and he was completely in white, with a turban. Presently a very fierce looking gentleman, also armed with sword and shield, came to his assistance, and others were close by. This I thought was rather too much of a good thing, as but few of my men were with me; so pulling out my Colt's revolver, I shot the two individuals I have named, and also four others. They were only about a yard off, and as I aimed at the breast, each fell dead immediately. I then called to my Highlanders to go in with the bayonet, and not to waste their fire, for they had been busy with their rifles. In a short time the court was full of dead bodies. Whilst this had been going on a number of the 93rd, tired of waiting to get in one at a time through a small hole, had gone round to the main entrance, where they contrived, after a while, to force the large gate, which had been protected by a sort of curved traverse. The 53rd, too, under Gordon, had succeeded in breaking down the bars of a large window, through which they soon entered. A general slaughter of the rebels therefore now took place, fighting going on all over the building. It was not long after this that I caught sight, in one of the rooms in the Secunder-Bagh, of a large Colour. The room was rather dark, but I could see it quite plain, leaning against the wall. Being determined to capture it, I made for the door, which was open; but no sooner did I try to enter, than two rebels cut at me. A namesake of my own had captured a Colour at the battle of Waterloo. He was a sergeant in the Scots Greys, and was given a commission. Having made up my mind to get this one, I now prepared for a final effort; so going back a few yards, I took a short run; and guarding my head as best I could with my sword, dashed through the doorway. They luckily missed me with their tulwahs; and after killing them both, I seized the Colour, which was heavy, and had a crimson case; having time to observe that my two antagonists were apparently native officers of some sort, being dressed, as far as I could make out, in blue, with gold sword-belts.
Although at the time savage and relentless, in consequence of the murder of my poor cousins, and the frightful barbarities perpetrated at Cawnpore and elsewhere, I now often regret that it was by my hand that eight of the defenders of the Secunder-Bagh lost their lives; and I earnestly pray that it may never again fall to my lot to take away the life of a human being. (From The story of a soldier's life; or, Peace, war, and mutiny, by John Alexander Ewart, 1881)
This was by no means the only encounter between the broadsword and tulwar on the day in question, though it may have been the only one where the opponent was a Sikh. Most of the Sikhs were fighting at the side of their Highland allies, as they charged into the Sepoy positions with sword in hand:
When the others had reached the front of the square building already referred to, they found the enemy in still greater numbers. "There were," says Colonel Malleson, "rebels in front of it, rebels within it, rebels in the courtyard behind it. But on this occasion," continues the Colonel, "boldness was prudence. The rebels outside, astonished by the sudden appearance of the two British officers and their following, ignorant of their numbers, and believing, it may be presumed, that the main entrance had been forced, ran hurriedly into the building, and attempted to make their way through a small door into the courtyard behind. The two officers and their men dashed after them, and a hand-to-hand encounter ensued." Cooper went straight into their midst. In his own words, he "worked away" at them with his whole strength, until he had laid many low with his sword. Then he was singled out by a Native officer—one of the Loodiana regiment which had mutinied at Benares—bearing a shield in his left hand and a tulwar in his right. Dropping his shield, the rebel—a very tall man—cut straight at Cooper, who, however at the same moment had aimed a blow at his antagonist. The tulwar cut through Cooper's feather bonnet and deep into his head, but the Highlander's sword had struck home, and the rebel fell dead. Cooper too, sank upon the ground. With him the struggle was over, unconsciousness supervened, and he knew no more till he had been carried beyond the region of the strife. (The Highland Brigade: Its Battles and Its Heroes , by James Cromb, 1886)
The Regimental Highland broadsword system of the 19th century has met with a great deal of skepticism, decried by some critics as an artificial and degenerate method unsuited for the battlefield. The performance of the Highland officers at the Secundra-Bagh should be enough to silence the critics. Highlanders armed with the broadsword and trained in the Regimental system took on superior numbers of Sepoy swordsmen, engaged them in hand-to-hand combat, and defeated them.
The guns proving decidedly troublesome, Stewart proposed to capture them, and, supported by a small party of the 93rd and 53rd, who had readily volunteered to follow him, he dashed forward with great spirit and daring. After a short struggle the attack proved entirely successful, and had the important result of securing the Mess-house, and enabling connections to be formed between this post and the Secundra-Bagh. For this gallant deed Stewart was elected by the officers of the regiment to receive the Victoria Cross. Meanwhile the fighting fiercely raged within the enclosure. The rebels, pressed from point to point, turned at bay and fought with the desperation of despair. Every staircase, corridor, and room was contested. The British were filled with a vengeful desire to bring retribution upon the miscreants for their long record of bloody misdeeds, and the word "Cawnpore" was hissed into many a dying wretch's ear.
Never had the avengers such opportunity as this. There was no chance of flight for the rebels here. This time they would have to fight to the bitter end. Quarter was neither asked nor given. That building was to be the huge sarcophagus of those on the one side or the other. Nor was there long any doubt as to which side would triumph. The power of the British arms was irresistible. Each man fought with a courage and fury which sometimes struck wonder, into the hearts of his opponents, and even paralysed their efforts at resistance. For hours the battle went on, nor did it end while one single rebel stood to level a musket or brandish a tulwar.
"Still," says Malleson, "numbers might have prevailed, when, at the critical moment, the Highlanders, the Sikhs, and the 53rd pressed in to the rescue"—entering by a second breach which had been made in a window on the right, in the vicinity of C. The rebels were now driven back on all sides; but from the towers at the angles of the enclosure they opened a terrific musketry fire, almost at point blank range. This they diversified by occasionally descending and engaging in close hand-to-hand combat; their numbers enabling them to inflict many casualties in the British ranks. Of the whole number who garrisoned the Secundra-Bagh at the commencement of the engagement, it was said that only four escaped, and Colonel Malleson thinks that the escape of even these four is doubtful.
From such a desperate fight it could not be expected that the Highlanders would escape scatheless. Burroughs, Cooper and Ewart, as we have already seen, were wounded early in the action. Lumsden was killed; Captain Dalzell shared his fate. Lieutenant Welch was severely wounded by a musket shot, and Ensign Macnamara received a sword-cut on the head. Donald Murray, the sergeant-major of the regiment, shot dead, had been one of the first to fall; and many of the rank and file were killed and wounded. Of the rewards given to the regiment for their heroic conduct on this occasion, we have already mentioned the Victoria Cross bestowed upon Captain Stewart. Another Victoria Cross was given to Lance-Corporal J. Dunlay, "for being the first man now surviving of the regiment who on the 16th of November 1857, entered one of the trenches of the Secundra-Bagh, at Lucknow, with Captain Burroughs, whom he most gallantly supported against superior numbers of the enemy." Captain Burroughs was also recommended by Colonel Leith Hay for the Victoria Cross—"for individual gallantry in the Secundra-Bagh, being the first who entered one of the breaches, and engaged in personal combat with greatly superior numbers of the enemy, in which he was wounded by a sword-cut."
The Highland broadsword saw plenty of combat service on this day, vindicating the effectiveness of the Regimental broadsword method. Out of all of the Regimental Highland broadsword manuals, the works of Henry Angelo have probably met with the most skepticism, both for their "Highlandness" and their effectiveness. But there was one Highlander, descended from the chieftains of the Clan MacGregor, who not only trained under Henry Angelo personally, but used his method successfully in single combat on the battlefield.
That man was Charles Metcalfe MacGregor. Charles Metcalfe MacGregor, a Highlander and descendant of MacGregor of Glengyle, served in India and China during the 19th century. He was an expert swordsman, and engaged in several sword fights with Indian warriors during the Mutiny. In a letter home, he credits his training under Angelo with saving his life in single combat against a rebel with a tulwar:
I have had two very interesting adventures since we came this side of the river Gumti. The first is as follows. I was out with two men just underneath the Daulatkhana: we were out skirmishing, and I had got separated from the rest of my company somehow. Well, I felt very thirsty, so I said to the men, 'Just break open that door and let us see if there is any water in the court.' They did so, and we went into the court. There was a well in it, and we commenced drawing some water, and just as I was drinking, one of the men shouted, 'Look out, sir!' and fired off his musket at one of four men who came rushing out of the house with tulwars in their hands. Luckily it knocked the fellow over, so that our numbers were equal.
I went at one fellow with my sword, and the two men went at the others with their bayonets. Well, they soon polished off their two; but I couldn't manage my chap so soon, as he was, like most of these niggers, a pretty tolerable swordsman. However, I had not quite forgot my lessons at Angelo's, and besides, these niggers can't understand the point; so I waited, not trying to hit my man, but keeping my eye on him (which, by the way, was very necessary, as he danced and jumped about like a madman, now hitting at my right side, then dancing round like lightning at my left).
I gave him a sharp jerking kind of cut on his knuckles, his sword dropped, and I was just going to give him No. 3 through his body, but he picked it up again too sharp for me, and began cutting at me again; but it was of no use, he couldn't hold it, and dropped it again, and he received the long-delayed No. 3 in his stomach. Over he went of course, and I picked up his tulwar and cut off his head very nearly with it. This is the first regular good single combat I have had, and I hope it may not be the last. If I had had a revolver, I could have polished the beggar off at once.
MacGregor's taste for single combat may seem a little bit odd, but he was a fanatic for sword training, and known for the strange delight he took in battle. In the words of Major T.A . Butler:
He [MacGregor] joined our regiment a little before the capture of Lucknow, and was attached to my company. You will know what his age was [seventeen and a half years]. He was not by any means a genial companion and we used to consider him of rather a sulky disposition. At mess he would sometimes sit all dinner-time and not say half-a-dozen words; but the moment there was any chance of fighting, it was extraordinary to see the change in his face and manner. It was a very common thing for one of the fellows to come into the tent and say, 'Look out, you fellows, we shall be turned out directly; the enemy are coming on,' just to draw MacGregor. The effect was magical. He immediately became full of smiles, and talked away merrily. He was the only man I ever met on service that I really believe loved fighting. He did not know what fear or danger were.
My company was the centre one when we entered the Yellow House at Lucknow . MacGregor rushed on ahead of the men, and though I shouted to him to keep back with the men, as the place was full of the enemy, he would not stop. A sepoy stepped out and fired his musket right in his face: luckily it only blew his cap off, and blackened his face. MacGregor killed the sepoy, and turned round to me with a blackened face beaming with satisfaction. He did not seem to have the slightest idea of the awfully narrow escape he had had. I need hardly say the men very soon got confidence in him, and would have followed him anywhere. I often heard them saying what a fine young fellow he was. After we got into Lucknow, as he was going through the courtyard of a house, a powerful sepoy sprang out on him. MacGregor fought him with his sword, and being a very good swordsman, and as cool as the proverbial cucumber, played with him for a few minutes, and then ran him through, and he was in the best of tempers for the rest of the day.
This peculiar, if not morbid, characteristic was noted more than once:
Lieutenant Charles MacGregor, attached to our regiment, was as usual to the front, and greatly distinguished himself by engaging in single combat with one of the bravest of the rebels, whom he reduced to eternal submission by sending his sword through his body up to its hilt. Brougham says, 'Mac returned looking very warm, and exceedingly wild and happy.'
MacGregor's brother Edward was trapped at Lucknow during the Mutiny, and MacGregor exchanged several letters with his mother about Edward's fate:
There are very bad accounts from Lucknow. The 32d Queen's and European officers are besieged by a force of 27,000 men, making the most fearful odds against the Europeans— upwards of twenty-seven to one. However, they'll never give in, and General Havelock is on his way to Lucknow with help. If it is God's will that Edward should not come safely through these dangers, we have the satisfaction of knowing that he will have died the death of a soldier, with his sword in his hand and his face to the foe—that he will have died as a MacGregor should die.
A few months later he learned what had happened:
My dearest mother, prepare yourself for the worst concerning Edward's fate. The list of survivors has come; in vain have I looked for the name of MacGregor. 0 God! That I should ever have to write such a thing—to think that poor Edward is cut off, so young, I can't believe it.
When the list came in I hardly dared look at the 41st. When I did, I sat staring at it, at the blank where Lieutenant MacGregor ought to have been. A kind of a chill came over me. I felt the blood fly away from my heart. I threw down the paper, rushed up-stairs, and flung myself on my bed and burst out into loud sobs. I tried to be cool, but I couldn't. Sooner would I have given up my own life than Edward should have suffered. We used to quarrel, but God only knows how I loved him, such a fine generous boy as he was. I used to be so proud of Edward, and now he is under the cold turf. It is His will that it should be so—that we should lose as fine a young fellow as ever breathed. . . .
He was generous, brave, and good-hearted. Oh why was he killed? Why wasn't I at Lucknow and he at Firozpur? . . .
Much better that I should die than such a one as Edward was. We arrived at Cawnpore the day before yesterday. I went off to Captain Saunders, and got dear Edward's sword from him: it was all covered with blood, and the hilt and the scabbard are all dented as if with bullets, showing that it has not remained idle in its sheath, but has drunk the heart's blood of more than one of these fiendish mutineers.
The Great Mutiny was a particularly bitter and ruthless struggle, with atrocities committed by both sides. MacGregor had been told horror stories of the rebel sepoys:
Mrs Robertson gave me an account of her escape from Hissar. One morning, just after breakfast, she heard some firing, but did not think much of it till her ayah rushed into the room and told her to fly, as the sepoys (Hariana Light Infantry) were coming to murder her. She ran out of the house and compound into the compound of a Lieutenant Barwell for safety; but she had hardly got there when about fifty or sixty sepoys came into the compound. She ran and hid herself in the garden under a bush, and while she was there she heard shrieks from the house. In a few minutes Lieutenant Barwell rushed out, dragging Mrs Barwell with a child in her arms. They made for a buggy (Barwell had just come in from breakfasting with another officer), and were just getting in when the sepoys came out of the house and rushed at them. Barwell fought like a lion, shot four men with his own hand, and wounded several others with his sword. He placed Mrs Barwell between the buggy and himself, while he tried to keep the ruffians off; and he was just going to turn to his wife, apparently to tell her to get into the buggy with the child, when he heard a bang behind him. He turned, and saw that a sepoy had got round to the other side and blown his wife's brains out. He caught hold of the child and ran towards the gate; but before he got twenty yards he was shot in the back. He fell, and just before he was murdered himself he saw the hell-hounds take the poor innocent baby, throw it up in the air, and catch it on the points of their bayonets. They then cut off his head with a tulwar.
When the tide of battle turned in favor of the British, the urge for vengeance drowned out any thoughts of compassion:
We killed a lot more, the whole of them behaving in the same disgusting cowardly manner as before: there was perhaps only one exception, and that was a man who came at me. I saw him lying crouching in a ditch, with nothing but his dhotee on. I asked him who he was. He got up on to his knees, put up his hands, and begged his life. I was just going to grant him it, when I saw something blue peeping out from some grass by the side of him. I went up to it, and lo and behold I there was a light cavalry jacket, as perfect as possible, with its orange facings and white trimmings.
Oh ho! my boy, thought I; so you're one of the dashing light cavalry, are you? I called out to a man by me to come and shoot him, as I was not going to let any of these sowars off. All of a sudden the beast jumped up, snatched a tulwar from underneath the grass, and rushed at me. As I was not prepared for him (my back being partly turned to speak to my man), he was on me before I knew where I was, and had given me a cut on the head with his tulwar. I saw the brute's eyes sparkle as he gave the cut, thinking he had done for me, and expecting to see me drop; but thanks to a solali topee, with a good pugree, the blow did not touch my head. I went at him at once, and gave him a cut across his cheek; but my sword not being sharp, it did not floor him as I expected, so I was preparing to give him point 3 in his stomach, when he turned and bolted. I went after him, and instead of giving him the prod in his stomach, gave it him through his back. He fell heavily on my sword, and broke it. I told one of our men to put a bullet through him, which he did. I then went up to look at his jacket to see what regiment he belonged to, and found he belonged to the 2d Light Cavalry— those fiendish beasts that murdered our women and children. You may be sure I was thankful I had polished that fellow off.
MacGregor's repeated successes in single combat may be attributed to his passion for training, which went far beyond the basic broadsword and cavalry training required of an officer:
I have enlisted a man in my service who is without exception the best rider that I ever saw. He is to teach me some of his feats, and under his tuition I hope to improve wonderfully in horsemanship, and learn to teach it to others. I must learn also the dragoon system of equitation; for though I don't approve of what I know of it, still one ought thoroughly to understand a system before one presumes to find fault with it; and moreover, by learning every system of riding, I shall be able to cull the good points and throw away the refuse. . . .
My ambition is to perfect myself in all the minutiae of my profession, as well as in the grander points— not only to be thought a good officer of cavalry, but the best cavalry soldier in India .I have also, for the last few months, been practising hard at spear and sword exercise on horseback, and can now beat any man in our regiment at either. I have also mastered several other feats of horsemanship. I can jump off a horse at full gallop, and jump on again without stopping him (this only requires nerve). I can jump on to a horse fifteen hands three inches high without catching hold of anything; and only yesterday I jumped on to a horse standing, off the ground on which I was—seventeen hands in one spring—without help from any one. I have been pistol-practising also, but do not succeed well at it. I can put ten bullets running, twenty-five yards off, into a space the size of a man's body, but this is nothing; some men can break a bottle twice out of three times at that distance. I hope to improve.
On one occasion, Lt. MacGregor was cut to the bone when a native sword struck him in the calf while he was leading a charge of irregular cavalry. His horse was also shot out from under him by the rebels. After he had recovered, he was transferred to China to fight in the Opium Wars. At the Battle of Sinho, MacGregor and the Sikh horsemen he commanded went into battle against a party of Mongols:
80 or 90 Tartars rushed from their front to take his guns in flank. On they came, with the most wild and unearthly cries. So unexpected was this attack that Captain Stirling had barely time to fire two rounds of case, when they were within 100 yards of the guns. There was no infantry near, but a guard of twenty-five of Fane's Horse, under the command of Lieutenant MacGregor, was attached to the battery. Now was the time, now the chance to test the Sikhs against the Tartars. Without a moment's hesitation, and regardless of numbers, Lieutenant MacGregor gave the word to charge, and away went the Sikhs in most gallant style. No flinching, no craning; every spur was well in the horse's side, when one-half the Tartars met them in full shock. The effect was instantaneous. One of the leading Sikhs ran his spear right through the body of a Mongol horseman, the head entering at his chest, and going out at his back. The spear broke in the middle: the Mongol fell to the ground spitted, and never moved a limb.
Lieutenant MacGregor singled out his man, and was in the act of spearing him, when another Tartar fired his matchlock within ten yards point-blank. The slugs hit the lieutenant in five places—three lodging in the chest, two in the forehead. For a moment he was blinded by the fire, which burnt his face; but the work was done. The Tartars dispersed in every direction, the whole affair lasting little more than a minute.
I am happy to say that Lieutenant MacGregor is fast recovering from his wounds, which, though severe, are not in the least dangerous. Nothing could be more gallant than his conduct, for he had no supports, and but a handful of men. The Sikhs were delighted with the result, which naturally inspired them with the greatest confidence, and proved their unquestionable superiority over the Tartar cavalry. One of his brother officers, who saw young MacGregor fall to the ground in the fight at Sinho, writes that, at first, they all made sure he had been killed, and one of them exclaimed, on reaching him, "Poor MacGregor's gone, I'm afraid!" whereupon the youth, desperately wounded as he was, cheerfully replied, " No! there's plenty of life in me yet." And again, when the surgeon approached to examine his wounds, which must have been very painful, "This is a nice birthday present they've given me!" he gaily cried, for it happened to be his twentieth birthday.
A day or two afterwards, whilst the disabled officer was lying hors de combat in his tent, there was an alarm that the enemy had attacked the camp. MacGregor, weak as he was, at once jumped up, and determined to sell his life as dearly as possible, propped himself up against the tent-pole, and, whilst he held his pistol with his left hand, strove to open his swollen eyelids with his wounded right hand in order to see the enemy. Fortunately it turned out to be a false alarm...
While recovering from his wounds, he wrote home that he was "jolly," and expressed the wish that the Tartars would "only go on fighting" so he could get another chance at them. At some point in the fighting he had received a blow to the head from a Mongol saber, which fortunately failed to cut through his turban. Now he was, in his own words, "game for another go." MacGregor was something of an admirer of the Tartars, praising them for their coolness under fire. His admiration for the Mongols only made him more determined to fight them again.
He got his chance, engaging and defeating the Tartars on several occasions with his Sikh cavalry. Upon reaching Peking, they burned and looted their way through the Emperor's palaces, which MacGregor complacently reports to have been rather profitable. Perhaps the blood of his MacGregor ancestors was coming to the fore!
Charles MacGregor was an ambitious and egotistical man, frequently expressing his desire to be wounded so that he could earn the Victoria Cross. He was also fond of boasting about his martial prowess:
Yes. I am improving in horsemanship; for the last two months I have never used stirrups, and can sit any horse over a jump without them. To give you an idea of my skill in spear and sword exercise. The other night, when the élite of the regiment were out at this practice, I got a spear and fought with three of them together, and was not once hit, but hit them all, one after the other. With the single-stick I can beat any two men, be they armed with spear or sword. With the spear, riding without a saddle or a blanket, I can beat the pick of the whole regiment, he riding in a saddle. This is nothing to what I hope to do in another year. In the hands of a man who can use it, the spear is a terrible weapon. I should like to have a bout with some of your regular, pipe-clay Lancers. In a future campaign I shall have double chances of distinction, for now I can use my weapons properly, and I have got as good weapons as can be got, and my sword has my mother's blessing.
On a subsequent campaign in Bhutan, MacGregor was shot on two separate occasions, which no doubt must have pleased him a great deal. He also fought in the campaign in Abyssinia, but does not appear to have had many opportunities for hand-to-hand combat there. He researched and published an extensive Gazetteer of the Indian sub-continent, which involved prolonged wandering through unfamiliar regions. He was married while still very young, but his wife died even younger, leaving him with a daughter to be raised by her sister. Returning heartbroken to India as a Lieutenant-Colonel, he was placed in charge of famine relief, and later of the protection of the frontier from Afghan bandit raids. In this role he advocated a policy of befriending the Afghan tribes, and putting an end to the cycle of frontier reprisal and vendetta. He went on journeys of exploration through Afghanistan and Persia, and traveled through Turkey on a secret intelligence mission. As he rose through the ranks of the British Indian Army through the years, he became known as a capable administrator with a particular interest in Intelligence work. He saw combat again at the Battle of Kandahar during the Afghan wars, and re-married after a number of years. He eventually attained to the rank and title of Major-General Sir Charles Metcalfe MacGregor, but by this point his sword-fighting years were long behind him. MacGregor died of a protracted illness in Cairo in 1887, after struggling to stay alive long enough to die gloriously in battle. He was only forty-six years old. His body was returned home to Scotland and buried at the MacGregor clan burial place in Glengyle.
(The Life and Opinions of Major-General Sir Charles Metcalfe MacGregor , 1888, and The Career of an Indian General in Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, 1888)